ShortBookandScribes #BookReview – The Lost Letters by Sarah Mitchell @SarahM_writer @Bookouture #BlogTour

Welcome to my stop on the blog tour for this lovely book which I’m reviewing today. My thanks to Noelle Holten for the place on the tour and the review copy via Netgalley.

A gripping book club novel about forbidden love, friendship and family secrets in a time of war. Perfect for fans of The Letterby Kathryn Hughes, The Notebook by Nicholas Sparks and The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society

Canada, present day 

When Martha’s beloved father dies, he leaves her two things: a mysterious stash of letters to an English woman called ‘Catkins’ and directions to a beach hut in the English seaside town of Wells-Next-The-Sea. Martha is at a painful crossroads in her own life, and seizes this chance for a trip to England – to discover more about her family’s past, and the identity of her father’s secret correspondent.

Norfolk, 1940

Sylvia’s husband Howard has gone off to war, and she is struggling to raise her two children alone. Her only solace is her beach hut in Wells, and her friendship with Connie, a woman she meets on the beach. The two women form a bond that will last a lifetime, and Sylvia tells Connie something that no-one else knows: about a secret lover… and a child.

But the tragedy of war brings heartbreaking choices. And a promise made between the two women will echo down the years, and could change everything for Martha…


I do love a dual timeline story, especially when one of the stories is set during the Second World War, so The Lost Letters had immediate appeal for me.

The two timelines are that of Martha in the present day and that of Sylvie in 1940s Norfolk. Martha’s father has just passed away before completing his memoirs and she finds that what he has left behind leaves her with more questions than answers. She leaves her home in Canada to spend the month of May in Norfolk to try and answer the questions she has: who is Catkins and why is a beach hut significant?

Sylvie meets a woman and child by a beach hut in Norfolk just before war breaks out and they become friends. And this friendship leads to some far-reaching consequences over the years that follow.

Normally with dual timeline stories, it’s the modern day story that really engages me, probably because there are usually a lot of discoveries to be made about the story in the past. But in the case of The Lost Letters I think I much preferred Sylvie’s story. It’s a perfect snapshot of wartime and how much it changed people and families. It’s so engaging, so interesting. I found it similar in a way to Kate Atkinson’s wartime writing – very intuitive and evocative.

But that’s not to say that Martha’s story is not engaging because it is. She’s a bit adrift after losing her father. Her daughter is away from home at Cambridge University and is drifting away from Martha. She’s wondering which way to turn in her life. I really enjoyed her journey of discovery about herself, her daughter, her family and her life.

I thought The Lost Letters was a beautifully written story. It’s not overly sentimental but it did move me and I think that was because of the quality of the writing and the way that I started to care about the characters and what happened to them. After a slightly slow start I found myself completely embroiled in a story that is quite melancholy at times, full of emotion and depth. After a debut of this quality I shall very much look forward to Sarah Mitchell’s next book.

After graduating from Cambridge University, Sarah Mitchell practised as a barrister in London for 20 years, working in the field of human rights and European Law. She was tempted to write fiction for a long while and finally signed up for an introductory creative writing course with the Open University. Two years later she took a sabbatical from the bar to do an MA in Creative Writing at the UEA and has never looked back. THE LOST LETTERS is her first novel, inspired by a walk on the beach at Wells-next-the-Sea to calm her nerves before starting the MA, and the decision her grandparents almost made to evacuate her mother to Canada at the start of the Second World War. Sarah now lives back in Norfolk – where she grew up – with her husband and three almost-grown-up children, and combines writing with some legal work.


Please leave a comment - I love to read them!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.